Many moons ago, there was a time when Pump and Dump schemes ruled the world of penny stocks. It seemed like the Wild Wild West of the stock market—a period of unregulated chaos where traders, brokers, and really anyone willing to take a gamble could make a quick fortune, or very easily lose everything. The very name of these schemes, “pump and dump,” tells you exactly how they worked. Stocks were hyped up and their prices “pumped” up to unsustainable levels, and then sold off, or “dumped,” once they peaked. The irony here isn’t lost when we title’d this article “The Rise and Fall of the Pump and Dump”—that’s literally what these stocks did: rise and fall.
The mechanics were pretty simple, yet devastating. Promoters would spread misleading or downright false information about a stock (via emails, websites, etc.), and nearly always some low-volume penny stock. The goal? To inflate the price. Once the stock price shot up due to the influx of buyers, those running the scheme would quietly dump their shares, making a big profit while everyone else was left holding the bag.
These schemes were no accident. Entire boiler room operations were set up to execute the plan. Brokers would make cold calls, send out promotional newsletters, and flood the market with hype. This was the golden age of pump-and-dump schemes, and if you were in the right circles, you knew how to spot them. The trick was simple: catch the pump early, buy in, and get out before the crash. But timing was everything. If you jumped in too late, you’d find yourself riding the rollercoaster down instead of up.
Savvy traders could make money off these schemes if they played their cards right. The more experienced ones knew how to “ride the pump,” buying into the stock just as the buzz was building. It wasn’t hard to spot the signs: unexplained surges in trading volume, sudden jumps in stock price, and a flood of unsolicited tips pointing to the “next big thing.” But probably one of the biggest red flags to identify one came when seeing green day after green day on the daily chart as the stock reached new highs every day. The key to successfully trading these pumps was knowing when to bail. Traders had to closely monitor volume and price action, watching for signs of weakness. As soon as momentum started to slow, it was time to sell before the stock tanked.
Some traders took it a step further by short selling the stock. For those who don’t know, short selling involves borrowing shares and selling them at the current inflated price, then buying them back later at a lower price once the stock inevitably crashes. It’s risky, but if timed correctly, the profits can be substantial. Traders who mastered this strategy made a killing off pump-and-dump stocks. But for most people, the outcome was far less rosy.
In reality, the vast majority of investors who got caught up in these schemes were just regular people, lured in by the promise of easy money. The “pump” phase was often so convincing that by the time the dump came, it was already too late. Most investors ended up with shares worth a fraction of what they paid, if that.
By the late 1990s and early 2000s, regulatory bodies like the SEC had started to catch on. The dot-com bubble was filled with similar schemes, and high-profile cases like the one depicted in The Wolf of Wall Street brought more attention to the problem. This marked the beginning of the end for classic pump-and-dump operations, as regulators cracked down hard on market manipulation, particularly in the over-the-counter (OTC) markets where penny stocks thrived.
In 2005, Regulation SHO was introduced to tighten the rules around short selling, and later, the Dodd-Frank Act increased transparency and accountability across financial markets. As a result, pump-and-dump schemes became less frequent in the modern stock market. Technology also played a part. FINRA’s OTC Bulletin Board and other platforms made OTC trading more transparent, and regulators started using sophisticated algorithms to flag unusual trading patterns. The golden age of pump-and-dumps was over.
But the story doesn’t end there. While traditional pump-and-dump schemes may have fallen out of favor in the stock market, they’ve found new life in the wild world of cryptocurrency. Crypto markets are largely unregulated, and the decentralized nature of digital currencies has made them a prime target for modern-day pump-and-dump schemes. Low-liquidity altcoins, in particular, are easy to manipulate because it doesn’t take much to drive up their prices.
Pump groups have sprung up on platforms like Telegram and Discord, where traders coordinate mass purchases of specific coins. Once the price rises to a certain point, the orchestrators sell off their holdings, leaving everyone else with worthless tokens. It’s the same old trick, just with a new asset class. While these schemes are illegal in traditional markets, they continue to flourish in the crypto space, especially with lesser-known coins.
Even in the stock market, you can still catch glimpses of pump-and-dump behavior. Look no further than the GameStop saga of 2021. While it wasn’t a traditional pump-and-dump, the meteoric rise in GameStop’s stock price, fueled by Reddit’s WallStreetBets community, had a similar flavor. Retail traders piled into the stock based on hype and momentum rather than fundamentals, driving the price to absurd heights. Some made massive gains, but many were left nursing losses as the price swung violently in both directions. It’s a modern twist on an old tactic, though in this case, the intent wasn’t malicious.
As markets evolve and new forms of trading emerge, the core lesson remains the same: be careful. Just because the fall of traditional pump-and-dump schemes in regulated stock markets is a win for market integrity, that doesn’t mean market manipulation is gone. It has simply moved into other areas, especially the crypto world. Today’s markets may seem safer with all the regulations in place, but they’re still filled with risks. The GameStop frenzy and crypto pump groups are proof that the spirit of the pump-and-dump is alive and well, just in a different form.
If you want to avoid getting burned, the best thing you can do is stay informed. Don’t fall for unsolicited stock tips or too-good-to-be-true promises of quick wealth. Do your own research, look at the company’s fundamentals, and be skeptical of anything that seems driven purely by hype. Whether it’s stocks or crypto, understanding what drives price movements is the key to making smart investment decisions.
In the end, the lessons from the rise and fall of pump-and-dump schemes are still relevant. If something sounds too good to be true, it probably is. And if you ever find yourself in a situation where everyone around you is saying to buy something because it’s going to the moon, take a step back and ask yourself: What happens after the pump? Because you don’t want to be holding the bag when the dump comes.
You must be logged in to post a comment.